You have three proposals in your inbox. All three promise more traffic, all three use the same words, and the prices differ by a factor of four. Meanwhile unsolicited emails keep arriving from firms offering to put you on page one for a small fee, and you cannot tell which of them is serious.
This page uses Google's own advice on hiring an SEO as the base, then gives ten questions with what a good answer sounds like, a worked comparison of a vague proposal line and a specific one, and a checklist to score each agency. The wider picture is on our organic SEO services page.
01What Google itself says about hiring an SEO
Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page gives plain advice on hiring. It suggests asking to see examples of previous work and success stories, asking whether the SEO will share all the changes they make to your site, and asking what results they expect and in what timeframe. It warns against firms that email you out of the blue, and against any company that is secretive or will not clearly explain what it intends to do.
On guarantees the page is blunt. It says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google, and that if someone guarantees first place in search results you should find someone else. Everything below builds on those points. If you first want the plain definition of the work, read what organic SEO services are.
02Ten questions to ask, and what a good answer sounds like
| Question | What a good answer sounds like |
|---|---|
| 1. Can you show previous work and what changed? | Named pages or sites with before and after data in Search Console, shared with the client's permission |
| 2. Which pages will you change in the first 90 days? | A list of pages and the single query each one targets, not a general plan |
| 3. Will you share every change you make to my site? | Yes, in writing each month, with access to the change history |
| 4. What results do you expect, and by when? | A range tied to your situation, with the reasons, and no promised position |
| 5. How will you get links to my site? | By earning them through content, press and partnerships, and never by buying them |
| 6. Who owns the accounts and the content? | You do: Search Console, analytics and everything published |
| 7. What will the monthly report show? | Impressions, clicks and enquiries by page, with the changes made |
| 8. How do you use AI in the work? | As a tool, with a person checking every page, as Google's helpful-content guidance asks |
| 9. What do you need from us? | Specific access and a named person to approve pages, not vague requests |
| 10. What happens if we stop? | Your pages, accounts and reports stay with you, and the contract has a short notice period |
Questions 1, 3 and 4 follow Google's advice in Do you need an SEO?. The rest are our own.
Questions 5 and 8 matter more than they look. Google's spam policies list link spam and scaled content abuse, and both are sold under friendly names. An agency that cannot say plainly how it earns links is likely buying them. Our explanation of white-hat link building shows what the earned version looks like.
03Red flags to rule out quickly
Good signs
- They ask about your customers and your sales before they talk about keywords
- They tell you what they will not do
- They give a range and a reason, not a date and a promise
- They give you access to every account
- They show you the check they will run after each change
Red flags
- A guarantee of first place or a date for page one
- An email you did not ask for offering to fix your rankings
- Secrecy about methods, or a refusal to name what they will change
- A package priced by the number of links per month
- A report that lists activity and no enquiries
04A vague proposal line and a specific one
The fastest way to compare agencies is to read one line from each proposal and ask whether you could check it a month later. Vague lines are not always dishonest, but they cannot be checked, so they protect the seller and not you.
Notice also what the specific line leaves out: it does not say the pages will rank. It says what will be done and how you will see it. The same standard applies to price. Our organic SEO cost calculator shows how scope changes the monthly figure, and our packages start at $2,000 a month, listed on the packages page.
Pay attention to who does the work. Some agencies sell to you with a senior person and hand the work to a junior team or to a tool. Ask who writes the pages, who checks them and who reads your report. Google's guidance on helpful content asks who created content and how, so the question is one Google also considers relevant. A written answer that names roles, not people, is enough, and it tells you how much attention your account receives.
Be careful with the pitch that mentions a secret method, a proprietary tool or a special relationship with Google. Google's hiring guide warns against secretive firms, and no agency has a way to pay Google for a position. A good agency shows its method plainly, because the method is ordinary work done carefully.
05How to score three agencies side by side
Send the same brief to each
Give all three your site address, your top three services and the cities or countries you want customers from, in one short message.
Ask the ten questions in writing
Written answers let you compare wording, and they can be checked later against what was delivered.
Check each claim
Open the example pages they show, look them up in a search, and confirm the pages still exist and are indexed.
Score each line of the proposal
Mark every deliverable as checkable or not. The agency with the most checkable lines is usually the one to trust.
06What to expect in the first 30 days of a good engagement
A good agency starts with an audit, not a pitch. In the first month you should receive a written list of faults found, the pages chosen for improvement with one query each, and a baseline from Search Console so that later change can be measured. You should also be asked for access to your site, analytics and Search Console. If month one is mostly meetings and a deck, the real work has not started.
It also helps to know the price of the pieces. An audit alone is a small, defined purchase, described on our SEO audit services page, and many owners start there to see how an agency thinks before they commit to a monthly fee. If you are in India and weighing local firms, the same ten questions apply, and our page on organic SEO services in India adds the local context.
07A five-minute check on an agency you already hired
If you already pay an agency, you can test the relationship today. Ask for the list of pages changed in the last three months. If the answer is quick and specific, the work is probably real. If it takes a week or arrives as a general summary, treat that as the red flag it is. Our guide on how long organic SEO takes helps you decide whether the results are late or only early.
Agency checklist
0 of 8 done08Contract terms to read before you sign
What the usual agency guides tell you
- Define your goals, check reviews, ask about reporting
- A list of questions for the sales call
- No price figure and no contract terms
- Advice written by an agency selling the service
What this guide adds
- The contract clauses that decide who owns what
- A price test you can run in your head, in hours
- A 15-minute check on the agency's own results
- A rule that no promise of a ranking passes the test
The top pages tell you what to ask in a call. None says what to look for in the contract, which is where the real exposure sits.
| Term | What good looks like | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Account ownership | Search Console, analytics and the domain stay in your name, and the agency is added as a user | The agency owns the property you depend on |
| Change log | A running list of every page changed, with the old and new text | "Proprietary process" and no record |
| Notice to leave | A short written notice period and your content stays yours | A long lock-in with fees for early exit |
| Who does the work | The named team and any subcontractor are declared | Work sent offshore or to freelancers without telling you |
| Links | Each link is listed with its live address, and paid placements are marked as sponsored | "Link packages" with no list of where they appear |
| Results clause | Describes work and reporting | A promised ranking or a promised number of clicks |
Google's own guide on hiring an SEO supports the last row: nobody can guarantee a number one ranking, and an SEO who is secretive about what they intend to do is a warning sign. You also never have to link to the SEO.
09What it costs, and a price test in hours
None of the top three pages gives a figure. BDC, a Canadian business bank, quotes an advisor saying a consultant costs about $3,500 a month and an individual specialist $75 to $100 an hour. Use the hourly figure to test any quote. Divide the monthly fee by $100 and by $75: at our fee of $2,000 a month that is 20 hours at the higher rate and about 27 at the lower. Now ask the agency how many hours a month it will spend on your site and who spends them. If the answer is a number far below those figures for a similar fee, you are paying for a brand and not for work.
10A 15-minute check on an agency's own search presence
Search its name plus the word reviews
Read what third parties say, not the testimonials on its own site.
Search one service phrase it sells, with no brand name
If it cannot rank for what it sells, ask how it will do it for you.
Open three of its case studies
Each should show the starting point, the pages changed and the Search Console clicks, not a screenshot of a ranking.
Ask for a reference you can call
Google's guide suggests asking for examples of previous work and success stories.
Check who answers
A senior person should be able to explain the plan in plain words without a slide deck.
If you already hired someone, our SEO audit services can check the work independently.
