You searched your service plus your city and saw a map with three businesses above everything else, none of them yours. Below the map sat a list of websites, and yours was somewhere on page two. Two different parts of Google are involved, and the work that moves one does not always move the other.
This page explains how the two differ, how Google says local results are ranked, how to decide which one you need, and what both look like for a clinic and for an online software company. The wider approach is on our organic SEO services page.
01The difference between organic SEO and local SEO
Organic SEO works on your website. Its goal is to make your pages appear in the standard list of results, often called the blue links, for searches such as "invoice software for accountants". Local SEO works mainly on your Google Business Profile, the listing that shows your address, hours, reviews and photos, plus the consistency of your business details across the web. Its goal is to appear in the map block and in map searches when someone looks for a business near them.
Both aim at the same outcome, which is an enquiry, but they use different levers. Our explanation of what organic SEO services include covers the website side in full.
| Point | Organic SEO | Local SEO |
|---|---|---|
| Where you appear | Standard results list | Map block and map searches |
| Main asset worked on | Your website pages | Your Google Business Profile, plus your website |
| Searcher's location matters | Rarely | Always, because distance is a ranking factor |
| Who it suits | Businesses that sell to anyone anywhere | Businesses customers visit or that serve an area |
| Reviews matter | Indirectly | Directly, and in volume and rating |
| Typical first fixes | Indexing, page content, links | Complete the profile, correct the listing details, collect real reviews |
Our own comparison. Local ranking factors come from Google Business Profile Help.
02How Google says local results are ranked
Google's Business Profile help page says local results are based mainly on three factors: relevance, distance and prominence. It describes relevance as how well a profile matches what someone is searching for, distance as how far each business is from the searcher, and prominence as how well-known a business is. It adds that links from other websites and the number and rating of reviews both contribute to prominence.
Relevance
Fill in every field of the profile, choose the right main category and list the services you actually offer, so Google can match you to the search.
Distance
You cannot change where you are. You can make sure your address and service area are correct so the distance is measured from the right place.
Prominence
Earn real reviews from customers and real mentions on other websites. Google's page says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking.
The link between the two types shows up in the last step. Links from other websites feed prominence, and earning them is also part of organic SEO, so the work on your website and your links helps your local position as well.
03Which one does your business need?
You need local SEO if
- Your customers visit a shop, clinic or office, or you travel to them in a set area
- Searchers add a place name, or Google shows a map when they search your service
- Competitors with fewer pages than you appear in the map results
- You can ask real customers for honest reviews
You need organic SEO if
- You sell online or serve clients in many cities or countries
- Buyers research and compare before contacting you
- No map appears when you search your main service
- You have no public address customers visit
04Worked example: a dental clinic in Pune
A dental clinic in Pune sees a map with three clinics when someone searches "dentist near me". The clinic gets most of its new patients from people who live within a few kilometres, so distance decides much of who appears. Its work is mostly local SEO, with a smaller piece of organic SEO for its treatment pages.
05Worked example: an online software company
An online accounting software company has no shopfront, so a map block never appears for "invoice software for accountants". Distance does not apply, because a buyer in another city is as good as a buyer next door. Its work is organic SEO: pages that answer the buyer's questions, a site Google can crawl and links from sites its buyers read.
06Three mistakes we see with local and organic work
- Different addresses in different places. The profile says one thing and the website another. Google's help page lists relevance as a ranking factor, and conflicting details make your business harder to match to a search.
- Buying reviews or asking only friends. Prominence draws on the number and rating of reviews, but reviews gathered in bulk or from people who never bought from you put the profile at risk. Ask real customers after a real job.
- Ignoring the website because the profile looks fine. Links from other websites feed prominence too, so a clear site with pages worth linking to supports your map position. Our SEO content services cover those pages.
A practical way to split work between the two is by the source of your last ten customers. Ask each how they found you. Customers who say they searched with a place name, or saw you on the map, point to local SEO. Customers who found a guide, a comparison or a service page point to organic SEO. If you cannot answer, set up a simple "how did you hear about us" question on your enquiry form for a month. A comparison of organic and paid search uses the same habit of measuring before spending.
If you want both done by one team, our organic SEO services cover the website side and the shared links, and the audit shows which of the two will move your enquiries first. Local ads, which Google sells through a separate product, are outside the scope of both.
07When you need both
Many businesses need both because customers find them in two ways. A solicitor's office may appear in the map for "solicitor near me" while a buyer searching "how to contest a will" finds only standard results. The first search is local SEO and the second is organic. A clinic, a law firm, a school, a home-service company and a multi-branch shop usually fall in this group.
The order matters when money is tight. Fix the profile and listing first, since it is faster and cheaper, then build pages for the questions that bring in standard results. The small business guide shows how to split a small budget.
Check which results show for your own searches, in five minutes
0 of 6 done08First question: does your business qualify for local results at all?
What most local vs organic guides give you
- A two-column table of audiences
- The assumption that every business can use local
- No price anchor
- One example, usually a bakery
What this page adds
- Google's eligibility rules checked against five business types
- A first-priority table for six business models
- An hours-based yardstick for any quote
- Worked examples that include the case where local is not available
The three top pages assume every business can do local SEO. Google's Business Profile rules say otherwise. A profile needs a real-world location customers can visit, or a business that travels to customers. P.O. boxes and mailboxes at remote locations are not accepted, and neither are virtual offices. A co-working office qualifies only with clear signage, customers received during business hours and your own staff there. Service-area businesses get one profile for a central office with a defined service area, with the address hidden, and Google says the area generally should not stretch past about two hours of driving from the base. Doctors, lawyers and similar professionals qualify when they are public-facing and reachable at the verified location.
| Business | Local profile? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Dental clinic with a street address | Yes | Customers visit the location |
| Plumber who travels to homes | Yes, as a service-area business | One profile, address hidden, defined area |
| Software company working remotely | No | No location customers visit or are visited at |
| Consultant using a rented virtual office | No | Google excludes virtual offices |
| Solo lawyer in a signed office with set hours | Yes | Public-facing practitioner at the verified location |
['Google Business Profile Help, Guidelines for representing your business', 'https://support.google.com/business/answer/3038177']
09Which one to do first, by business model
| Business model | Do first | Then |
|---|---|---|
| Single clinic or shop | Local: profile, reviews, location page | Organic pages for services |
| Several branches | One location page per branch plus a profile each | Organic pages for service topics |
| Service-area trade | Local profile with the service area | Organic pages for each service and town |
| Ecommerce shop with no storefront | Organic: category and product pages | None needed from local |
| Software company | Organic: use-case and comparison pages | None needed from local |
| Solo expert selling anywhere | Organic: one page per problem solved | Local only if clients visit an office |
Our organic SEO services cover the website side, and the local side needs the profile only a verified owner can manage.
10What to pay for local SEO, and how to compare quotes
There is no standard price list for local SEO. BDC, the Canadian business bank, quotes an advisor saying a consultant costs about $3,500 a month, and an individual specialist $75 to $100 an hour. Use the hourly figure as a yardstick: at $100 an hour our $2,000 a month is 20 hours of work, and at $75 it is about 27 hours. Ask any local quote how many hours it contains and what each deliverable is. A single location with a profile and a handful of pages is a smaller scope than a full organic programme, so a lower figure there is reasonable, as long as you can see the deliverables.
