You paid for an audit. A PDF of ninety pages arrived, full of red scores and screenshots. Your developer opened it, did not know where to start, and closed it. Three months later nothing on the site had changed.
That happens when an audit reports everything it found, in the order the tool produced it. A useful audit reports what to do, in the order that matters, and says who does it. This page shows how we write one, with a sample finding before and after, what you can check yourself for free in Google Search Console, and when you do not need to buy one. It is the entry point to our organic SEO services.
01What a useful SEO audit is
A useful audit is a decision document. Every finding in it has five parts: what is wrong, which pages it affects, why it matters for search, who fixes it, and how much effort it takes. The findings are ranked by how many important pages each fix helps, so the first item is the one to do on Monday.
Audit tools produce scores. Scores are useful for spotting a pattern, but a score does not tell you which fix to make first. The ranking is a judgement, and it is the part you are paying for.
02The five areas we check
| Area | What we check | Example of a finding |
|---|---|---|
| Technical foundation | Crawl access, indexing, canonicals, redirects, speed, JavaScript rendering | The sitemap lists redirecting addresses |
| Content and search intent | Whether each key page matches one buyer search, and which pages compete | Two pages target the same phrase |
| On-page elements | Titles, descriptions, headings, internal links, structured data | Every service page has the same title pattern |
| Links | Who links to you, how, and what looks built | One keyword makes up most of the link text |
| Measurement and AI visibility | Search Console set up, conversions tracked, AI crawler access decided | Enquiries are not tracked by source |
The technical area is covered in depth by our technical SEO services, the content area by our SEO content services, and the link area by our link building. The audit tells you which of these you need first, and whether you need any of them.
03How one finding is written up, before and after
The same fault can be reported so no one acts, or so someone acts the same day. Here is one finding in both forms, for a generic clinic site.
How we rank the findings
We rank by two things: how many important pages a fix helps, and how little effort it takes. A fix that helps forty service pages in an hour goes above a fix that helps one page in a week. Where a fault blocks indexing, it goes first whatever the effort, because a page Google has not stored cannot gain from any other fix.
| Field | What it says | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Pages affected | The exact addresses or page group | Eight service pages |
| Why it matters | The effect on search, in one sentence | Google cannot tell the pages apart in results |
| Owner | The role who makes the change | Marketing, developer or host |
| Effort | Time for the owner, in hours or days | Half a day |
| Check | How you will know it worked | Click rate on those pages in two weeks |
An audit written this way can be handed to a developer on Monday without a meeting. If a finding cannot be written with all five fields, we say what information is missing, instead of guessing.
04What you can check yourself for free in Google Search Console
Before you buy an audit, spend thirty minutes in Search Console. It is free, and four reports give you a first view of every area above.
| Report | What it shows | What to look for |
|---|---|---|
| Page indexing | Which URLs Google indexed and why others were not | Important pages in Page with redirect or Discovered - currently not indexed |
| Performance | Clicks, impressions, click rate and average position by query and page | Pages with many impressions and few clicks |
| Core Web Vitals | Real-visitor speed data grouped by similar pages | Groups marked Poor or Need improvement |
| Links | Top linking sites, top linked pages, top linking text | One repeated link phrase or unrelated sites |
Source: Google Search Console Help pages for each report.
Google says the Page indexing report shows which pages it could not index and why. It also says Crawled - currently not indexed is common and not necessarily a problem, so check only the pages that matter to the business. The Performance report's default view is the past three months, and its average position is the topmost result from your site.
A 30 minute self-check
0 of 8 doneIf the self-check turns up one or two clear faults, send them to your developer and wait a month. If it turns up several, or you cannot tell what is serious, an audit is the next step.
05When you do not need an audit
Google's guide on whether you need an SEO says small local businesses can often do much of the work themselves, and suggests reading its SEO starter guide first and hiring help only if you still need it. We agree, and there are four cases where we would tell you to skip an audit.
An audit suits you if
- Traffic fell and you do not know why. Our <a href="/why-organic-traffic-dropped/">guide to organic traffic drops</a> shows what to rule out first.
- You rebuilt or moved the site recently.
- You paid for SEO before and cannot tell what was done.
- You need a ranked list to hand to a developer.
Skip it if
- Your site has fewer than about twenty pages and Search Console shows them all indexed. Read <a href="/organic-seo-for-small-business/">organic SEO for small business</a> and act on it.
- You already know the fault, such as a blocked robots.txt. Fix it and re-check.
- You have no one to act on the list. Fix that first, since a ranked list still needs an owner.
- Your site is new and has no content yet. Build first and audit later.
06How the audit runs with us
You give us read access
We ask for Search Console access and your analytics, never your passwords.
We crawl and read the reports
We crawl the live site and read the four reports above against it.
We rank the fixes
Each finding gets an owner, an effort and a position in the order.
We walk through the list
We go through the top fixes with your team and hand the rest over as tickets.
What you receive is the ranked list, the evidence behind each line, and a short note on which layer to fund first. If you want us to make the fixes, they sit inside our organic SEO services, from $2,000 a month. If your team makes them, the audit stands on its own. See our organic SEO checklist for the free version of the same areas.
07What an SEO audit costs, and what moves the price
What a typical audit gives you
- A score out of 100 and a long export
- Findings with no page counts or owner
- A price set by page count alone
- An audit with no one to make the fixes
- A generic list that fits any site
What we do instead
- A ranked list: one finding per fix, with pages, reason, owner and effort
- Findings that point to evidence you can open yourself
- AI visibility checked with a named question list on three engines
- A note on which layer to fund first, even when the answer is that none needs it
- Fixes made inside the same plan if you want us to make them
Published audit prices run from hundreds to thousands of dollars, and scope explains the spread. One large US agency publishes an audit from $8,600 over about 45 days for up to 70 pages, with add-ons such as a $1,200 in-depth link audit. Its own pricing guide gives $650 to $1,500 for sites under 50 pages, $2,500 to $7,500 for ecommerce and $10,000 and up for large enterprises.
| Driver | A cheaper audit | A costlier audit |
|---|---|---|
| Pages and templates | Under 50 pages, few templates | Thousands of pages, many templates |
| Scope | One area, such as technical | Technical, content, links, measurement and AI visibility |
| Competitor work | Not included | A scorecard against up to 3 competitors |
| Implementation | A report only | Training or hands-on fixes |
| Time | Days | Weeks. Published audits quote 3 to 5 weeks and about 45 days |
WebFX, SEO audit services; OuterBox, SEO audit services
Compare the price per ranked finding with an owner, not the price per page. A cheap audit with 300 unranked warnings costs you the time it takes to rank them. Our fixes sit inside the plan described on the packages page.
08Can ChatGPT do an SEO audit? What it can see and what it cannot
A chat tool can help you read an audit and explain a finding. It cannot audit your site alone, because an audit rests on data about your site: what Google has indexed, which pages were crawled and what real visitors experienced. A chat tool sees only what you give it, and Google warns that AI output may be inaccurate and should be fact-checked.
| Source | What it shows | What it cannot show |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Which pages are indexed, queries, clicks, impressions and Core Web Vitals field data | Why a page is weak, or what competitors do |
| A site crawl | Redirects, titles, canonicals and links across the site | What Google decided to index |
| A chat tool | Explanations, ticket drafts and a second reading of what you paste | Your live index status unless you supply the data, and it can be wrong |
| An audit by a specialist | Judgment about which fault to fix first | Anything it was not given access to |
Google Search Central, Using generative AI content
09Which audit for which moment
| Moment | What the audit should cover | What to leave out |
|---|---|---|
| Before you hire anyone | Indexing, whether your main pages match the search, and how you measure enquiries | A long backlink report |
| After a traffic drop | The pages that lost clicks, indexing, and what changed on your site that week. See why organic traffic dropped | A rewrite of every page |
| Before a redesign or a platform move | Addresses to keep and redirect, templates to preserve | Content strategy |
| After a launch | Indexing of new pages, redirects and mobile checks | A competitor scorecard |
| For AI visibility | Buyer questions asked on three engines, who is named, which pages are cited. See AEO services | A score with no question list |
OuterBox recommends lightweight technical checks each month and full audits several times a year. A small site often needs less. A simpler rule is to audit again after any large change to the site, not on a calendar.
