You sat through an agency pitch led by someone sharp. Then the contract started, and your account went to a junior you had never met, who sends a template report on the first of the month.
If that is why you are searching for a consultant, you are looking for accountability more than a job title. This page sets out what a consultant should do, when you need one, and when an agency or an in-house hire is the better call.
01Consultant, agency or in-house: which one you need
| Consultant | Agency | In-house hire | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who does the thinking | The senior person you hired | Often a junior, under a manager | One employee, alone |
| Best when | The problem is unclear and judgment matters | You need volume across many markets | SEO is a permanent, daily function |
| Speed to start | Days | Weeks, after onboarding | Months, after hiring |
| The weak point | Limited hours | Handoffs and template work | No second opinion, and a salary either way |
| Ask before you sign | Who writes and who implements? | Who exactly works on my account? | Who will check their work? |
02What a good consultant does in the first 30 days
Reads your data before talking
Search Console, analytics and a full crawl. Opinions come after the evidence, and each one points to a page or a search you can open yourself.
Asks how you make money
Which service has the best margin, which customers stay, what a lead is worth. Rankings for searches that do not pay are a hobby.
Writes a short priority list
Ten items at most, ranked by effect on enquiries, each with the effort it takes and who does it.
Fixes the first blockers
The work starts inside the first month. A plan that only gets presented is a slide deck you paid for.
Agrees how success is counted
Enquiries from organic search, the pages behind them, and positions for a named list of searches. You both sign off on the list.
03How we work as consultants
We are a small senior team. The people who diagnose your site are the people who write the pages and send the pitches, so nothing is lost between a strategy document and the work. You have one point of contact who can answer a technical question without checking with someone else.
We also keep the method open. Every change is logged with its reason, and your team can read the list at any time. If you have developers or writers in-house, we direct and review their work. If you do not, we do it. The fee is the same $2,000 a month either way, and the scope is on our main organic SEO services page.
"His knowledge about SEO is so in-depth! He really brings great value to the table."
Said about our lead strategist, on LinkedIn.
"His deep expertise in SEO and digital strategy helped us significantly boost our online visibility and drive consistent traffic growth."
Said about our lead strategist, on LinkedIn.
04Seven questions to ask any SEO consultant
Tick each one you got a straight answer to
0 of 7 doneGoogle's own page on hiring an SEO adds a warning: no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and you should be wary of anyone who claims a special relationship with Google. Our longer guide on how to choose an organic SEO agency covers what a good answer to each question sounds like.
05When a consultant is the right hire
Hire a consultant if
- You do not know why the site is not ranking
- You were burned by template agency work
- You have a team that needs direction and review
- You want to talk to the person doing the thinking
Hire differently if
- You need fifty pages a month in six languages: that is agency volume
- SEO is your main channel and needs someone daily: hire in-house and use a consultant to check the work
- You want someone to run ads as well
- You want a guarantee of position
Want to see what the method has produced? The case studies show the outcomes, and the calculator tells you what an enquiry would cost at your numbers. Prefer to start alone? The organic SEO checklist is free.
06How consultants charge, and what each model rewards
What hiring by job title gets you
- A senior name on the sales call and a junior on the account
- A plan that is a list of services
- Advice before your data is read
- A report built to look busy
- A price that depends on which model you were quoted
What we do instead
- The people who diagnose your site also write the pages and send the pitches
- A short priority list ranked by effect on enquiries
- Evidence from Search Console before any opinion
- A report that starts with enquiries
- One flat fee: $2,000 a month
A consultant charges in one of four ways, and each way rewards a different behaviour. Knowing which one you are offered tells you what you are paying for. Published ranges are wide: a roundup of organic SEO agencies reports $2,000 to $3,500 a month for smaller engagements and $6,500 to $15,000 for full-service business-to-business and software programmes.
| Model | You pay for | It rewards | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hourly | Time spent | Hours, not outcomes | A bill that grows while the plan stays vague |
| Monthly retainer | A set scope each month | Steady delivery | A scope that is only a list of counts |
| Project or sprint | A defined piece such as an audit or a strategy | Finishing the document | Nobody owns the fixes afterwards |
| Share of results | Part of what the work earns | Whatever is easiest to count | Rankings can be counted and profit cannot. Google says no one can guarantee a position |
Ours is a monthly retainer of $2,000, with the audit, fixes, pages, links and reporting inside it. The packages page lists what you receive, and the audit page describes the first piece in detail.
07What to bring to the first call so the hour is worth it
A consultant can only be as specific as the material you hand over. Bring the same things to every first call and you can compare consultants fairly, because each one answers the same brief.
Bring these eight things
0 of 8 done08A fifteen-minute test on one real page
The cheapest way to judge a consultant is to hand over one page and see how they read it. A good reply is specific, ranked and honest about what cannot be known. The test works before you sign and costs neither side much.
Pick a page
Choose a service page that should bring enquiries and does not.
Ask three questions
What search is this page meant to answer? What is the most likely reason it is not found? What would you change first, and how will we know it worked?
Score the reply
Use the table below. Two weak answers out of four is a reason to keep looking.
| Question | A good answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| What search does this page answer? | Names one search in the customer's words | Lists five keywords |
| Why is it not found? | Points to evidence: not indexed, wrong intent, thin, no links | "It needs more authority" |
| What changes first? | One change, with the page and the effort | A list of ten |
| How will we know? | A named measure and when you will look | "Rankings will improve" |
