Case studyReset with Ola is the first name in Google's AI Overview for "burnout coach geneva".Read itCase studyChatGPT names Physio Buddy first for a lower back pain physiotherapist in Chandkheda.Read itCase studyBolo Media is named first by ChatGPT and Google AI Mode for Gujarati video ads.Read itIn their words"He increased our organic traffic and leads by 4x-5x multiple." Founder, Content Whale.Read it
PPerson EngineOptimization

Organic SEO services / Organic SEO consultant

Organic SEO consultant

An organic SEO consultant who does the work, not the handoff

The person on the sales call should be the person reading your Search Console.

The short answer

An organic SEO consultant is a senior specialist you hire directly to diagnose why your site is not found and to fix it. The difference from an agency is who does the thinking: with a consultant, the person who plans the work also does it or directs it daily. We work that way as a small senior team, for a flat $2,000 a month.

8 minute readWritten by the Person Engine Optimization team
Built for visibility onGoogleChatGPTPerplexityGeminiClaude
Ranked by what moves enquiries first
A short list in priority order beats a long report.

You sat through an agency pitch led by someone sharp. Then the contract started, and your account went to a junior you had never met, who sends a template report on the first of the month.

If that is why you are searching for a consultant, you are looking for accountability more than a job title. This page sets out what a consultant should do, when you need one, and when an agency or an in-house hire is the better call.

01Consultant, agency or in-house: which one you need

Three ways to get organic SEO done
ConsultantAgencyIn-house hire
Who does the thinkingThe senior person you hiredOften a junior, under a managerOne employee, alone
Best whenThe problem is unclear and judgment mattersYou need volume across many marketsSEO is a permanent, daily function
Speed to startDaysWeeks, after onboardingMonths, after hiring
The weak pointLimited hoursHandoffs and template workNo second opinion, and a salary either way
Ask before you signWho writes and who implements?Who exactly works on my account?Who will check their work?

02What a good consultant does in the first 30 days

  1. Reads your data before talking

    Search Console, analytics and a full crawl. Opinions come after the evidence, and each one points to a page or a search you can open yourself.

  2. Asks how you make money

    Which service has the best margin, which customers stay, what a lead is worth. Rankings for searches that do not pay are a hobby.

  3. Writes a short priority list

    Ten items at most, ranked by effect on enquiries, each with the effort it takes and who does it.

  4. Fixes the first blockers

    The work starts inside the first month. A plan that only gets presented is a slide deck you paid for.

  5. Agrees how success is counted

    Enquiries from organic search, the pages behind them, and positions for a named list of searches. You both sign off on the list.

Example: advice you can act on
VagueYour site has thin content and weak authority. We recommend improving content quality, building high-quality backlinks and enhancing the user experience across key pages.
SpecificYour "bookkeeping services" page is 140 words and has no price, so it sits at position 31. Add the three packages with fees, the software you use and two client examples. Then link to it from the home page menu, where it is missing.
Why it works: The first paragraph could be sent to any site on the internet. The second names the page, the position, the cause and the change. If a consultant's sample work reads like the first, keep looking.

03How we work as consultants

We are a small senior team. The people who diagnose your site are the people who write the pages and send the pitches, so nothing is lost between a strategy document and the work. You have one point of contact who can answer a technical question without checking with someone else.

We also keep the method open. Every change is logged with its reason, and your team can read the list at any time. If you have developers or writers in-house, we direct and review their work. If you do not, we do it. The fee is the same $2,000 a month either way, and the scope is on our main organic SEO services page.

5.0 of 5, LinkedIn service review
"His knowledge about SEO is so in-depth! He really brings great value to the table."
Karan RaghaniIndependent creative and social media consultant
Said about our lead strategist, on LinkedIn.
"His deep expertise in SEO and digital strategy helped us significantly boost our online visibility and drive consistent traffic growth."
Tarun PeswaniWorked on the same team at Content Whale
Said about our lead strategist, on LinkedIn.

04Seven questions to ask any SEO consultant

Tick each one you got a straight answer to

0 of 7 done

Google's own page on hiring an SEO adds a warning: no one can guarantee a number one ranking, and you should be wary of anyone who claims a special relationship with Google. Our longer guide on how to choose an organic SEO agency covers what a good answer to each question sounds like.

05When a consultant is the right hire

Hire a consultant if

  • You do not know why the site is not ranking
  • You were burned by template agency work
  • You have a team that needs direction and review
  • You want to talk to the person doing the thinking

Hire differently if

  • You need fifty pages a month in six languages: that is agency volume
  • SEO is your main channel and needs someone daily: hire in-house and use a consultant to check the work
  • You want someone to run ads as well
  • You want a guarantee of position

Want to see what the method has produced? The case studies show the outcomes, and the calculator tells you what an enquiry would cost at your numbers. Prefer to start alone? The organic SEO checklist is free.

06How consultants charge, and what each model rewards

What hiring by job title gets you

  • A senior name on the sales call and a junior on the account
  • A plan that is a list of services
  • Advice before your data is read
  • A report built to look busy
  • A price that depends on which model you were quoted

What we do instead

  • The people who diagnose your site also write the pages and send the pitches
  • A short priority list ranked by effect on enquiries
  • Evidence from Search Console before any opinion
  • A report that starts with enquiries
  • One flat fee: $2,000 a month

A consultant charges in one of four ways, and each way rewards a different behaviour. Knowing which one you are offered tells you what you are paying for. Published ranges are wide: a roundup of organic SEO agencies reports $2,000 to $3,500 a month for smaller engagements and $6,500 to $15,000 for full-service business-to-business and software programmes.

Four ways a consultant can charge
ModelYou pay forIt rewardsWatch for
HourlyTime spentHours, not outcomesA bill that grows while the plan stays vague
Monthly retainerA set scope each monthSteady deliveryA scope that is only a list of counts
Project or sprintA defined piece such as an audit or a strategyFinishing the documentNobody owns the fixes afterwards
Share of resultsPart of what the work earnsWhatever is easiest to countRankings can be counted and profit cannot. Google says no one can guarantee a position

Ours is a monthly retainer of $2,000, with the audit, fixes, pages, links and reporting inside it. The packages page lists what you receive, and the audit page describes the first piece in detail.

07What to bring to the first call so the hour is worth it

A consultant can only be as specific as the material you hand over. Bring the same things to every first call and you can compare consultants fairly, because each one answers the same brief.

Bring these eight things

0 of 8 done

08A fifteen-minute test on one real page

The cheapest way to judge a consultant is to hand over one page and see how they read it. A good reply is specific, ranked and honest about what cannot be known. The test works before you sign and costs neither side much.

  1. Pick a page

    Choose a service page that should bring enquiries and does not.

  2. Ask three questions

    What search is this page meant to answer? What is the most likely reason it is not found? What would you change first, and how will we know it worked?

  3. Score the reply

    Use the table below. Two weak answers out of four is a reason to keep looking.

How to score the answer
QuestionA good answerA weak answer
What search does this page answer?Names one search in the customer's wordsLists five keywords
Why is it not found?Points to evidence: not indexed, wrong intent, thin, no links"It needs more authority"
What changes first?One change, with the page and the effortA list of ten
How will we know?A named measure and when you will look"Rankings will improve"
Example: a reply to the fifteen-minute test
Weak replyYour page needs better content, more backlinks and improved technical SEO. We would build authority over time.
Good replyThe page for 'accounting software for dentists' is not being shown because Google chose the category page as the main version. The Page indexing report says 'Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user'. Make the product page's text clearly different from the category page and link to it from the menu. Check the report in a week.
Why it works: The good reply points to evidence you can open, and its first action is small. It also says how to check the result.

On video

Watch our lead strategist explain it

Short videos from our lead strategist. They load only when you press play.

Direct Connection of SEO with Personal Branding
Direct Connection of SEO with Personal BrandingHow SEO and the consultant's own name work together. Watch on YouTube

On LinkedIn

What we have written about this on LinkedIn

Post by our lead strategist
This is how I became an SEO expert, by avoiding these mistakes and focusing on ethical, long-term strategies. (Well, seriously, DONT's are equally important as DOs) I never rely on spammy backlinks from...

A post from our lead strategist on the SEO mistakes to avoid.

Open on LinkedIn

If you would rather hand this over

We do this work for a flat monthly fee.

One plan covers the technical fixes, the pages, the links and the reporting. You see what was shipped each month and which enquiries came from search.

$2,000a month
  • Technical fixes, shipped
  • Pages written for buyers
  • Links earned, never bought
  • A monthly report on enquiries

Questions people ask

Hiring an organic SEO consultant, answered plainly

What does an organic SEO consultant do?
They diagnose why your site is not found in unpaid search, rank the fixes by effect on enquiries, and either do the work or direct your team to do it. The value is judgment: knowing which ten of a hundred possible tasks matter for your site.
Is a consultant cheaper than an agency?
Sometimes, and it is the wrong comparison. Compare what you get per month of fees: who does the work, how specific the plan is, and how results are counted. Our fee is a flat $2,000 a month.
Can a consultant work with my in-house team?
Yes, and it often works best. Your developers and writers know the business. We set the priorities, write the briefs, review the work and measure the result.
How do I check a consultant is good before hiring?
Ask for a sample priority list and a sample report from past work, with client details removed. Specific pages, searches and numbers are a good sign. Generic phrases that could describe any site are a bad one.
Do you offer a one-time consultation?
The closest thing is an audit, which ends with a ranked list of fixes your team can act on. The audit page explains what it covers and when you do not need one.
What does organic SEO mean?
Organic SEO means earning visibility in the unpaid results of search engines, and now in AI answers that draw on them. You do not pay for each click. You earn the position by fixing the site, publishing pages that match what buyers search for, and gaining mentions on other sites.
How much do SEO consultants cost?
It depends on the model. A roundup of agencies reports $2,000 to $3,500 a month for smaller engagements and $6,500 to $15,000 for full-service business-to-business programmes. Hourly and project pricing also exist. Compare what each covers and who does the work. Ours is a flat $2,000 a month with the work inside it.
Is SEO dead or evolving?
Evolving. Google says AI Overviews and AI Mode use its core ranking systems and need no special markup, and Search Console counts their traffic in the Performance report. A consultant now has to cover Google results and what AI tools say about you. The skill that matters most is still diagnosis.
Is SEO a high paying job?
It can be, but pay varies by country, seniority and whether the person is employed or independent. We have not opened a salary survey we trust enough to quote, so we give no figure. For a buyer, the useful numbers are the fee or hourly rate and what it covers.